The event was held Thursday night, April 12th at the MidRivers community meeting room in Glendive, MT, which was hosted by The Eastern Montana Patriots Organization (TEMPO) and sponsored by the Montana Policy Institute (MPI). While Foxs truth may have changed, he certainly has not. [9] Variety said the film examined the process of fracking, giving counter arguments for the Gasland documentary, especially the flaming faucets scene. Hydrofracking - hype or hoax? We would love to host this debate in an open forum in front of an audience of citizens, some of whom support fracking and others who do not. What if the Allies had landed and the Nazis retreated back to Germany without putting up a fight? he added Conflict is necessary in a movie. On December 17, 2012 Mark Cuban's AXS.tv announced that they had acquired the television rights to FrackNation, and the documentary had its television premiere on January 22, 2013 at 9 p.m. Indeed, over more than four decades, our litigation, coverage and trial lawyers have gained a reputation for taking on and prevailing in the most challenging and technical cases, frequently parachuting in to assume unresolved matters from other law firms. Charles Oliver As stated in our letter to you of March 13, 2013, we want to be transparent. TODD MYERS: Two films, watched back to back, best reveal the conflict and confusion involved in making rational energy policy. Gasland vs. Fracknation: A Discussion of the Future Litigation, History of oil and gas exploration and associated environmental/product liability litigation, Digging deep into the operations of high-volume horizontal hydraulic fracturing - a complete overview of the process, Chemicals and substances used and extracted as part of the hydrofracking process - a closer look at the epidemiology, science and potential medical issues associated with shale gas exploration. Drilln Man question: The coincidental nearby location, the fact the films are at the same time, the two films use the same advertisement poster- the local writers taking heat from Fox. You can follow the progress made towards funding on FrackNation.com as well as KickStarter.com. While Fox tends to infuse emotions, McAleer takes his discussions to a personal level. Gasland Vs Fracknation Essay, Best Argumentative Essay Topics Death Sentence, Example Of Research Paper About Behavior, Report Writing Access 2013, Descriptive Essay Editor Website Gb, Volte Case Study, Reverse Funnel Paragraph College Essay 4248 Did You Ever Wonder How and Why the Left Is Able to Push Their Narratives Almost Unhindered? It will address the following topics: More information is available on the event website. FrackNation will go head-to-head with GasLand II, Josh Fox's planned sequel to GasLand (2010), the highly effective anti-gas propaganda piece. From knowing comes caring, from caring comes change. It reached the fundraising target of $150,000 within three weeks of launching.[16]. By THR Staff. Moreover, it is apparent that Foxs name is repeatedly and unnecessarily mentioned throughout the film. Fox is clearly depicted as the villain in "FrackNation," from a "Gasland" post-screening Q&A where Fox refuses to answer McAleer's simple questions, to a scene at Los Angeles' Hammer Museum where Fox literally flees the camera. The proposed lease Fox briefly shows in his . Environmentalists are terrifying average people with well made movies and making documentaries presenting untrue facts, which are easily debunked with the truth.. The story made major headlines and was shown on major TV news channels as well as discussed on talk radio. His documentaries popularised the now-debunked claim that fracking causes contaminated water. From an ordinary audiences eyes, this act is degrading because it is immature to select such portrait from all other decent pictures of Fox. Many . 3.2.2023 12:01 AM, Jacob Sullum An EPA video obtained via a Freedom of Information Act request shows the same husband and wife litigants threatening visiting federal agents when told that their water was uncontaminated. Wilson Elser is the preeminent defense litigation firm in the United States. House Passes Bill to Show How Much Bidens Executive Orders Affect Inflation, George Santos' CNN Response Is a Master Troll Move, Hawley Confronts Biden Nominee In Tense Exchange on Past Tweets: 'You Lied Under Oath'. Gasland vs. FrackNation Their dueling documentaries the sequel to Fox's Oscar-nominated "Gasland" aired July 8 on HBO and McAleer's "FrackNation" aired the following night on AXS have clear aims when it comes to hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, the gas drilling method by which chemical-laced fluid is injected into the . This documentary is the anti-"Gasland" with its highly favorable perspective on the controversial method of drilling known as fracking. FrackNation was featured as the most popular project in Kickstarter's film section. The burning tap water scenes in Gasland and Gasland II have stoked fears about the potential dangers of fracking. People in the oil and gas industry know their jobs are not going away. email: editor@bakkenoilbiz.com If you havent yet watched FrackNation, attend a screening in PA or OH during April, or buy the DVD at: //FrackNation.com. Terms under which this service is provided to you, California - Do Not Sell My Personal Information, Here's the Other Rural Town Being Screwed Over by Joe Biden, Chicago Police Chief Calls It Quits After Lightfoot Defeat, Evil Fox News Versus 'Trusted CNN,' Part 2, The American Way Versus the Politicians' Way, 'Ecogrief' Seminar Is the Latest Leftist Attack on American Energy, Russias Biggest Weapon (and China, too) is Fossil Fuel-Generated Energy. The fact is environmental issues are far more complex and this simple mud-slinging does nothing to educate the public or fill in the knowledge gap on responsible behaviour change to help the bigger issues of environmentalism and modern living. http://blogs.wsj.com/experts/2014/11/27/energy-lessons-from-both-gasland-and-fracknation/. Frack Nation tweeted and FaceBooked to raise almost $250,000 in a very short time to finance their documentary on Kickstarter.com. News Corp is a global, diversified media and information services company focused on creating and distributing authoritative and engaging content and other products and services. TheDelaware Valley Marcellus Association (DVMA) is sponsoring a screening of the excellent documentary film FrackNation at the Bryn Mawr Film Institute on April 10 (Philadelphia, see this calendar announcement for details). Yesterday, the DVMA issued the following press release/open letter to Fox: Today the Delaware Valley Marcellus Association issued the following open letter to Josh Fox, producer of the anti-fracking films GASLAND and GASLAND II: Since 2010, your documentary film GASLAND has impacted public opinion about the natural gas industry and hydraulic fracturing. The lessons learned are simple; the anti-fossil fuels crowd is winning the propaganda battle as most of the pro- side is busy making a living and most important we can win IF we can maximize our involvement in social networking, i.e. .css-16c7pto-SnippetSignInLink{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;cursor:pointer;}Sign In, Copyright 2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved, March sale - 25% Off Avis coupon code 2023, Wayfair promo code: 10% off any single purchase, Sign up to Stock Advisor for $79 for 1 year. The magazine noted that the documentary did a thorough job of technical information and personal stories of farmers who live near fracking locations. [citation needed], McAleer told Politico he was motivated to make the film by what he saw as the "one-sided approach taken by the media, 'outsiders' and 'urban elites'" on the fracking process. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. He presents the other side of the story and offers answers to Foxs evidences. View all posts by bringitgreen. The play was running at the prestigious New York Public Theater as part of the equally prestigious Under the Radar theater festival. Of course the timing is relevant, Cuban told The Hollywood Reporter. Ive met and spoken to Phelimhave you? FrackNation will air July 10th on AXS TV, the day after Gasland II is scheduled to play on HBO. McElhinney and her husband produced several other documentaries debunking environmentalists cases against different issues, such as mining in Romania. Gasland is a 2010 American documentary film written and directed by Josh Fox.It focuses on communities in the United States where natural gas drilling activity was a concern and, specifically, on hydraulic fracturing ("fracking"), a method of stimulating production in otherwise impermeable rock. Review: Gasland vs. FrackNation. Other pro-hydraulic fracturing attendees entered without any problems into the theater where the Gasland Part II movie was being shown. . Gasland: More Bad Than Good? Hydraulic fracturing, is a technique used by the oil and gas industry to extract natural gas from rock thousands of feet underground. 3.1.2023 4:21 PM, 2022 Reason Foundation | The films must constantly stay relevant when -Most headlines have at the most a 10 day life span. The HBO PR person would not give out full names or business cards, but we did find and confirm the fact they worked for HBO and are connected to promoting Gasland Part II. FrackNation starts from a bogus and willfully cordoned off point-of-view, and exhibits a desire to grind axes more than uncover truth. [needs update] AXS.tv timed the debut to coincide with the theatrical release of Promised Land, Matt Damon and John Krasinski's feature film about how the fracking debate affects a rural town. Isnt this all just bull. Even the ups and downs experienced by the filmmakers are revealed. When I confronted Fox with this information, he admitted knowing this but withheld this vital information from viewers because its not relevant.. The American Denominator in CCPs Global Dominance: Communist Moneyman and American Traito To Catch the Chinese Tiger by the Tail, America Needs a Unified Strategy, Chicken Little Alarms Voiced Over Repeal of Section 230. Online & On Campus Programs . Akin to "FrackNation" with "Gasland 2" director Josh Fox, the film spends much time attacking former Vice President Al Gore in ad hominem fashion, with the film serving as a response Gore . It seems at times there is a mandate in documentaries to be the winner of truth, god of journalism at the expense presenting a holistic view of the problem. Josh Fox's 2010 film Gasland portrayed it as a major danger to the environment in general and drinking water in particular. But those measures are likely to diverge this year, with one signaling the Feds work is nearly done and the other suggesting the opposite. To get attention requires conflict Josh Fox refuses to talk to FrackNation creator Phelim McAleer direct in public- Fox denied movie goers, including Phelim, admittance to premiere of Gasland Part IIs at the Tribeca Film Festival in NYC on Sunday, April 21, 2013 at the 3:30 PM showing in the SVA Theater. The main evidences of Fox in supporting his claim that fracturing is harmful to human and environment include flaming water flowing from faucets, brownish color of water collected from residents in affected areas, remains of dead animal species, and illnesses reported by residents that started only when fracturing became prevalent. I had seen some stories about problems here in Texas with fracking and with the corporations refusing to tell about the stuff they were pumping into the ground. The latter created fear in people about climate change having an immediate affect on our lives if we continue to depend on fossil fuels as our mainstay. Some of these pro and con-hydraulic fracturing movies are made by TV people for what they thought was a controversial subject. From the farmers of the Delaware River Basin, for whom . Both pictures use a formula for drama and addiction. Review: Gasland vs. FrackNation "Gasland" and "FrackNation" are two opposing documentaries which are dealing on the issue of hydraulic fracturing and its impacts on human and environment. We hope that you will accept our invitation. To conclude, Fox and McAleer have valid reasons for their documentaries. Phelim finds himself shut down by Josh Fox and his lawyers, and so asks the public to crowd fund his documentary to explore further some of the misleading facts sensationised by the cunning Fox. Gasland is Josh Foxs reaction to a proposal made by a gas company to lease his land in Pennsylvania. .because its planned that way. Mapping out the geographic litigation - where is the drilling occurring and suits being filed? Josh Fox, the director of gasland, wouldn't even debate any of the questions raised to him by Mr. McAleer. McAleers film completes the debate about hydraulic fracturing. True enough because his interview invites to oil and gas company executives were declined. Web. The purpose of the debate would be to, in an open forum and atmosphere of mutual respect, fully air the controversial issues surrounding Marcellus Shale development. Let us know how we can further our mission, and better serve the hard-working folks in the Bakken. Please visit the source responsible for the item in question to report any concerns you may have regarding content or accuracy. Details. Josh Fox has been accused of lying - again. Please Like our Bakken Oil Business Journal FaceBook page to find out more about the good, the bad and the ugly in the petroleum industry. Kyle Smith for the New York Post wrote that McAleer should have earned an award for taking on the "fear mongering" in Gasland. During a time of globally heightened debate, Journalist Phelim McAleer travels across the U.S. and Europe to speak with scientists and Americans living in fracking areas, in order to uncover the science behind the process and to determine its true consequences. He commented after the presentation: The movie is not yet set for release but the promo was excellent. Bakken Bob van der Valk But lets not forget that Fox (albeit accidentally) ensured Donald Trumps election by forcing all left-wing candidates to take the anti-science route and pledge to ban fracking. Gasland was released to critical acclaim and Oscar nomination in 2010, a harsh and stark take on the realities of fracking in the US. But when several of the landowners who leased their land for drilling sue [8] a gas company for making their water flammable, a movement of anti-fracking activists creates a political pressure that results in a series of bans and moratoria on fracking that put the development on hold. From courses of actions disclosed, an ordinary audience can infer that their objectives are legitimate. Debunking Gasland. Anti-fracker Fox nervously and amusingly ducks many attempts by McAleer to get information about the evidence for his assertions in Gasland. Others firmly believe if there had not been any screaming and shouting, there would have been no reason for security to deny them access to the movie. Ann McElhinney saved her real harsh words about Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) current dealings with sustainability. The real news is overlooked- news impacting working men and women and our national energy security. These scenes are sensational, frightening and easily burned into one's false impression of fracking. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Ronald Baileyis science correspondent atReason. Im not quite sure how you make the leap of FrackNation and a sick, twisted bomber in Bostonbut I tried to stop figuring out the anti-drilling mind a long time ago. Phelim McAleer is a journalist, producer, podcaster, and filmmaker. #mc_embed_signup{background:#fff; clear:left; font:14px Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif; }
But Josh Fox or his people seemed to have more than willing to preview parts of Gasland Part II and work with FrackNation on some level; sharing advertising with the contrasting film in headlines and social media. "FrackNation" makes a convincing case that Fox . The answer is not clear, like the answer on whether to frack or not. You are paid to write promotional stories said the contact- Films and major corporations are all about making profits. It was Josh Foxs Gasland which inspired us to produce our film FrackNation and reveal the actualtruth about fracking. At the start of his documentary, he . Moreover, he reiterates that there is no credible association between fracturing and the mentioned circumstances and that the claims depicted in Gasland are misleading. If you have never seen it, you . Phelim McAleer initially tries to hold a public conversation with Josh Fox about some of the questionable Gasland facts. FrackNation is a feature documentary created by Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney, the directors of Not Evil Just Wrong and Mine Your Own Business, and Magdalena Segieda, that aims to address what the filmmakers say is misinformation about the process of hydraulic fracturing, commonly called fracking.. | Fox produced and directed the documentary Gasland and its follow . | "[6], Official synopsis: "In FrackNation journalist Phelim McAleer faces threats, cops, and bogus lawsuits questioning green extremists for the truth about fracking. Bakken Oil Business Journal It will also respond to "Gasland," a film made by Josh Fox . Did Christopher Wray Just Make Things Worse for Himself and the FBI? Phil Mcaleer creates the documentary FrackNation to supposedly expose the truth about fracking to clear up the . It is funny in upending the pathetic lies of . This article originally appeared in print under the headline "Debunking Gasland". 3.1.2023 5:00 PM, Emma Camp The former honors student went from living in a luxury penthouse with other executives at FTX to becoming the latest member of the crypto exchanges inner circle to plead guilty to fraud. Towns like Glendive, Baker, Circle and Terry are going to have their growing pains, but I dont think anyone wants the oil production to go away. The 70-minute documentary destroys the claims made in Gasland. July 7, 2013. Bring it green is my familys journey from central London to the rest of the world as we relocate overseas. Change). Hours after, the grassroots showing of FrackNation and Gasland Part II, HBO associates including their PR people were made available for a sit-down at the Bull Frog Brewery in Williamsport. FrackNation had a theatrical premiere in New York on January 7 and in Los Angeles on January 11, 2013. McAleer makes a good case against Fox's movie. COLLEGE SCHOLARSHIP OPPORTUNITY AVAILABLE TO FUTURE ENERGY LEADERS, Raymonds Folly The Codell Play of the Denver Basin, North Dakota Oil and Gas Tax Revenue Study Released, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. All Rights Reserved. [1], FrackNation was inspired when documentary filmmaker Phelim McAleer asked Josh Fox, the director of the 2010 documentary Gasland, some questions at an event in Chicago. FrackNation versus Gasland. Doc Talk is a biweekly column devoted to documentary cinema, typically featuring an essay concentrated on a currently relevant topic for discussion followed by critic picks for new theatrical and home video releases. In fact, the image that made him famous, a scene in which a Colorado homeowner lit his tap water on fire, has been debunked. If not fossil fuels, then what do we use for our daily energy consumption?. [11], Some positive reviews claimed that the film was able to successfully refute not only the factual claims of Gasland but also some of the emotional testimonies. The film is structured as a road movie with McAleer as the journalist/narrator on the search for the truth about the costs and benefits of hydraulic fracturing aka fracking. According to Josh Fox a journalist who directed "Gasland" a 2010 documentary found that fracking is making people sick, contaminating water, and affecting wildlife. The second was made in response to Gasland that seeks to discover the truth about hydraulic fracturing, debunking the claims made by Josh Fox along McElhinney also commented about the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) ruling frequently against hydraulic fracturing and just reversed its decisions in Pavillion, WY, Fort Worth, TX, and Dimock, PA. (LogOut/ Petroleum Engineering student at Montana Tech comments on both films. Fracking does not cause burning tap water. They would promptly be walked over to the frac pit and having to point where the drain plug is located for doing shallow research on the subject of hydraulic fractuting in pre-production. Privacy Policy | And Clinton wonders why she lost these states Now Fox has re-emerged with a play, The Truth Has Changed. Both films have been able to survive by attacking each other . With "FrackNation" opening Tuesday, he offers this view from the ground.) The Philadelphia premiere of FrackNation will be held on April 10, 2013 at the Bryn Mawr Film Institute in Bryn Mawr, PA at 7 p.m. Tickets, which are $10 in advance or $15 on the night of the show, are available at //www.marcellusdelval.org/register-for-fracknation. My question was inspired by the odd coincidence about how could these film makers maintain so much animosity between them while showing films down the street from each other at similar times and locations? Fox has been making stuff up since the beginning of his documentary career. Phelim does a grand job of (more) truthful journalism presenting wider angles and facts on fracking, a bold move in a time when anti-fracking movements have such momentum and power. TERRY, MONTANA - The word "passionate" is the one word comes to mind immediately upon first meeting documentary filmmaker Ann McElhinney. Directed byPhelim McAleer Ann McElhinney. Facts outside those illustrated by the two filmmakers are lost on the masses. He is known for his films The Gosnell Movie and Fracknation. Continue reading your article witha WSJ subscription, Already a member? Both documentaries show ample representation of how data were gathered. Gasland Film Analysis. Unsurprisingly, Fox responded with vitriolic allegations. The new feature documentary FrackNation demolishes the anti-fracking claims made in Josh Fox's Emmy-winning film Gasland. The Drill'N Man was allowed to ask any questions and got the answers. | Fox presents his disapproval to hydraulic fracturing while McAleer presents his support for oil and gas exploration. While Fox was promoting his film project McAleer confronted him about the historical records of people being able to ignite methane in water at "burning springs" long before fracking started. | [10] The National Review noted that FrackNation did an excellent job refuting Gasland based upon the scientific research in the film. Energy Lessons From Both 'Gasland' and 'FrackNation'. She shared her current passion explaining hydraulic fracturing or shale oil and gas by showing a sneak peak of her film . Moreover, the way he directed the camera created a drama that catches interest and attention. In its early years, EPA acted primarily as the nations environmental watchdog, striving to ensure that industries met legal requirements to control pollution. Imbued with continuous fabrications, Gasland by Josh Fox is a less reliable argument on hydraulic fracking compared to FrackNation by Phelim McAleer. FrackNation vs GasLand Fracking is big in Texas. Many have seen the film Gasland, a documentary-style film by Josh Fox. For those of you who dont know who Josh Fox is - allow me to explain. (LogOut/ Gasland vs. Fracknation: A Discussion of the Future Litigation on Gas Exploration Perrin Conferences Date: March 13, 2013 Location: Webinar - 2:30 - 3:45 p.m. EST The webinar will feature four speakers including Carl J. Pernicone (Partner-New York), co-chair of Wilson Elser's national Insurance-Reinsurance Coverage practice. Groundtruthing Academy Award Nominee Gasland. The New York Times 24 February 2011. Greg Cross, owner of Cross Petroleum in Glendive, MT, attended this sneak preview. FrackNation is an independent film, wants to remain independent of the oil and gas production industry. During a time of globally heightened debate, Journalist Phelim McAleer travels across the U.S. and Europe to speak with scientists and Americans living in fr. Paul Harvey used to say on th4e radio: And now for rest of the story. The film looks at the process of fracking for natural gas and seeks to address the concerns . Essentially Gasland II relies on conflict between the tow producers to keep it in the headlines. History; News; Events; Strategic Plan . Emotionally driven arguments create a dependent audience with fans who know nothing of the industry outside the movies themselves. Phelim McAleer is a journalist, producer, podcaster, and filmmaker. McAleer talks to scientists, industry honchos and rural Americans affected by fracking, revealing some surprising facts. An expression of thoughts, ideas, aspirations, opinions, and many more. It was NWPOA, a Pennsylvania group of private landowners involved in leasing their lands for drilling, who produced the lease Fox shows in his film. Apparently Fox is a coward and not willing to defend his workhe refuses to respond or even acknowledge the invitation from DVMA. FrackNation. In short, if it is a choice between believing Fox and believing workers at the Public Theater, I think its clear who is the more habitual liar. [13], There were negative reviews of the film. With scant concern for earth science and demonstrable fact, GasLand earned an Academy Award nomination and stirred up anti-fracking hysteria nationwide with its memorable footage of flaming faucets. Yes, Josh awakens the public to the atrocities to fracking a very very important message but he could have still achieved it without the help of fraudulent imposters as revealed by Fracknation. If Mr. Fox accepts the Delaware Valley Marcellus Associations invitation, debate with Mr. McAleer will take place immediately after the screening at approximately 8:10 pm. Unfortunately, Phelims campaign to reveal the truth whilst eye opening and thought provoking, also succumbs to the temptation of embellishing the truth for effect and thus leaves us still scratching heads on who to trust. If you want a closer look at what was going on in the Public Theater, Helen Shaw is a critic at the leftist Vulture website, which publishes pieces on culture. While these two globe trotters post videos on YouTube and trying to turn the spotlight on them, the industry continues to make progress. . Its about money- you must disconnect yourself from the message. Phelim McAleer's film FrackNation argued the contrary and poked . [20], Cuban says he welcomes the controversy and discussion, and the release of FrackNation should only fuel the fracking debate. Terry, Montana For this assignment I chose to watch two conflicting documentaries, Gasland and FrackNation. However, both have their own weaknesses that make the films vulnerable to critiques. In a statement, the theaters spokeswoman Shareeza Bhola stated that the play was cancelled following multiple reports of Josh Foxs violation of our code of conduct. In a subsequent interview, she was more specific, stating, It was a series of verbal abuses to the staff that led to the plays cancellation. This documentary is the anti-"Gasland" with its highly favorable perspective on the controversial method of drilling known as fracking. FrackNation is a feature documentary created by Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinney, the directors of Not Evil Just Wrong and Mine Your Own Business, and Magdalena Segieda, that aims to address what the filmmakers say is misinformation about the process of hydraulic fracturing, commonly called fracking. It just so happens that I can help in this conundrum. National update on the current claims and defenses in hydrofracking litigation, Overview of current state and federal legislation and regulations - update on pending proposals, Drilling down to the top insurance issues - emerging coverage and policy questions, Crunching the numbers: potential damages from personal-injury and property damage cases. 12 June 2015. Terms Of Use, The Government Is Subsidizing Microchip FirmsWhile Making It More Expensive To Produce Microchips, Fox's Excuses Reinforce Dominion's Defamation Case, FDA Cracks Down on Animal Tranquilizer That Is Sometimes Mixed With Fentanyl, Ohio Woman Says Cops Broke Her Wrist for Recording During Traffic Stop. If your only exposure to hydraulic fracturing, or fracking the process of extracting natural gas from shale has been Josh Fox's alarming documentary, "Gasland," then "FrackNation . "[15] John Anderson of Variety found the film's use of staged confrontations ineffective and manipulative, writing that "McAleers sandbagging of Carol Collier, executive director of the Delaware River Basin Commission, seems pointless, except as an effort to get an anti-fracking official to look like shes got something to hide.